Introduction
When you’re working on heavy-duty projects like automotive repairs, construction, or home improvement, a good cordless impact wrench is essential. Among the top contenders are the Milwaukee 2967-20 and Makita XWT08Z. Both offer incredible performance, but which one is right for you? Whether you’re a professional mechanic or a weekend DIY enthusiast, choosing the best tool for your needs is critical.
In this guide, we’ll break down the features, performance, and value of both impact wrenches in detail. By the end, you’ll know exactly what each model has to offer, so you can make the best purchase decision.
Key Features of the Milwaukee 2967-20
Milwaukee has long been a trusted brand in the power tools market, and the Milwaukee 2967-20 impact wrench upholds that reputation. It combines power, compactness, and efficiency into one sleek package. Let’s explore its features in more detail:
Torque and Performance
The Milwaukee 2967-20 is known for its 1,400 ft-lbs of nut-busting torque and 1,000 ft-lbs of fastening torque. This makes it a reliable tool for tasks like tightening lug nuts on vehicles, assembling machinery, or performing repairs. Whether you’re working on a car engine or a construction project, this impact wrench can handle tough jobs with ease. The Powerstate brushless motor ensures optimal power efficiency and extends the life of the tool, meaning you’ll get plenty of usage out of it.
Compact and Lightweight Design
One standout feature of the 2967-20 is its compact design. Weighing just under 7 pounds, this impact wrench is light enough to reduce hand fatigue during long projects. The ergonomic handle with a rubber-overmold provides a secure grip, and the reduced length makes it easier to work in tight spaces. Whether you’re working in an engine bay or navigating under a car, this tool’s slim profile can easily reach hard-to-access areas.
M18 Battery Platform
The 2967-20 is part of Milwaukee’s M18 system, which is one of the most popular battery platforms among professionals. The M18 5.0Ah battery is compatible with over 200 tools in the M18 lineup, offering excellent versatility. Plus, Milwaukee’s REDLITHIUM™ technology ensures that the battery delivers more run-time and lasts longer than standard batteries. This system is ideal for professionals who need tools that are ready to go whenever you are.
LED Light for Dark Spaces
Another great feature of the 2967-20 is its built-in LED light. This feature helps you work in low-light or dark environments, illuminating your work area for better visibility. Whether you’re working in a dimly lit garage or during a nighttime roadside emergency, this small yet helpful addition can make a significant difference in getting the job done.
Key Features of the Makita XWT08Z
Makita, another industry leader in power tools, has brought its own innovation to the cordless impact wrench market with the Makita XWT08Z. This model is packed with features that make it a solid choice for anyone who needs top-tier performance and durability.
Exceptional Torque and Performance
The Makita XWT08Z sets the bar with 2,000 ft-lbs of nut-busting torque and 1,480 ft-lbs of fastening torque. This is one of the most powerful impact wrenches in its class, making it an excellent option for the toughest jobs, such as tire changing, heavy machinery repair, and other industrial tasks. Powered by Makita’s brushless motor, the XWT08Z offers more energy efficiency and extended motor life compared to its brushed counterparts.
Tough Construction for Harsh Environments
One of the standout features of the Makita XWT08Z is its IP56 rating, which means it is dust- and water-resistant. If you’re working in wet or dusty conditions, this tool is built to withstand those environments, making it a solid choice for construction sites, outdoor projects, or areas with high humidity.
Ergonomic and Comfortable Design
Despite its power, the Makita XWT08Z is built with ergonomics in mind. The tool is well-balanced and designed to reduce user fatigue. It weighs about 7.9 pounds, which is slightly heavier than the Milwaukee 2967-20, but the added weight helps provide better stability when you’re dealing with heavy-duty jobs. The rubberized grip and soft-touch handle improve comfort, making it easier to maintain control even during extended use.
LXT Battery System
The Makita XWT08Z is powered by the 18V LXT lithium-ion battery system, a technology that charges quickly and provides a longer run-time than older battery technologies. While the XWT08Z’s charging time isn’t as fast as Milwaukee’s M18, it still offers great performance for most applications. Plus, the LXT battery is compatible with a wide variety of other Makita power tools, providing great versatility for those already using the Makita platform.
Performance Comparison
Let’s put these two impact wrenches head-to-head and see how they stack up in real-world performance.
Torque and Power Output
When it comes to torque, the Makita XWT08Z delivers a slightly higher nut-busting torque of 2,000 ft-lbs, compared to Milwaukee’s 1,400 ft-lbs. This means the Makita can break free stubborn bolts and nuts more effectively, making it a great choice for tougher jobs. However, the Milwaukee 2967-20 still delivers impressive performance for most tasks, and 1,000 ft-lbs of fastening torque is more than enough for regular automotive repairs, home improvement, or light construction.
Speed and Efficiency
The Milwaukee 2967-20 boasts a max speed of 2,000 RPM and 2,400 IPM, which makes it a high-speed tool for fast driving of fasteners. The Makita XWT08Z offers 1,900 RPM and 2,200 IPM, slightly slower in terms of speed, but it compensates for this with its higher torque and greater power. For those needing both speed and high torque, the Milwaukee is a solid option, but the Makita shines when raw power is needed.
Durability and Weather Resistance
The Makita XWT08Z wins when it comes to durability. Thanks to its IP56 rating, this impact wrench is designed to resist water and dust, making it better suited for working in extreme conditions. The Milwaukee 2967-20, while highly durable, has a slightly lower IP54 rating, meaning it can withstand water splashes and dust but isn’t as resistant as the Makita when dealing with harsher environments.
Weight and Comfort
When it comes to ergonomics, both impact wrenches offer comfortable designs, but the Milwaukee 2967-20 is a little lighter and more compact, making it easier to handle for long periods. The Makita XWT08Z, although slightly heavier, offers an excellent balance that reduces user fatigue during extended tasks. For extended use, both tools are well-designed to keep discomfort at bay, though the Milwaukee may be more comfortable for users who prioritize lightness.
Price and Value for Money
When it comes to cost, the Milwaukee 2967-20 is generally more affordable than the Makita XWT08Z. Here’s a quick breakdown of the price differences:
Milwaukee 2967-20 Price
The Milwaukee 2967-20 is priced around $200 to $300, depending on whether you’re purchasing it as a bare tool or as part of a kit with a battery and charger. Given its high torque and reliability, it offers excellent value for money.
Makita XWT08Z Price
The Makita XWT08Z tends to be $300 to $350, which is a bit more expensive. However, the extra torque and enhanced durability may justify the cost if you need a tool that can handle tougher conditions.
Which is the Better Value?
If you need a highly powerful and versatile tool for general use, the Milwaukee 2967-20 might be the best value for money. But if you’re working in extreme environments and need higher torque for heavy-duty tasks, the Makita XWT08Z could be worth the investment.
Pros and Cons: Milwaukee 2967-20 vs Makita XWT08Z
Milwaukee 2967-20 Pros:
- Affordable and great value for its features
- Lightweight, compact, and easy to handle
- Excellent power and speed for regular jobs
- Part of the M18 battery system for greater versatility
- LED light for working in dim conditions
Milwaukee 2967-20 Cons:
- Slightly lower torque than the Makita XWT08Z
- Lower IP rating for dust and water resistance
Makita XWT08Z Pros:
- Higher nut-busting torque for more power
- IP56 rating for working in harsh environments
- Brushless motor for better efficiency and longevity
- Well-balanced and ergonomically designed for comfort
Makita XWT08Z Cons:
- More expensive than the Milwaukee
- Slightly slower in terms of speed and RPM
- Heavier, which might cause fatigue during long use
Conclusion
Choosing between the Milwaukee 2967-20 and the Makita XWT08Z depends on your specific needs. If you’re looking for a high-performing tool that’s affordable and suitable for most jobs, the Milwaukee 2967-20 is a solid choice. It provides great torque, speed, and comfort, making it perfect for a wide variety of applications.
On the other hand, if you need maximum torque for extremely tough tasks and are willing to invest in a slightly more expensive tool, the Makita XWT08Z might be the better option. Its superior durability and higher nut-busting torque make it ideal for heavy-duty projects and harsh work environments.
Ultimately, both tools offer exceptional performance, so it all comes down to your budget and the types of jobs you’ll be tackling. Whether you’re a professional or a DIY enthusiast, either one will be a great addition to your toolbox.
FAQs
Which impact wrench is better for heavy-duty use, the Milwaukee 2967-20 or the Makita XWT08Z?
For heavy-duty use, the Makita XWT08Z is the better choice. It delivers 2,000 ft-lbs of nut-busting torque, which is higher than the Milwaukee 2967-20 (1,400 ft-lbs). The Makita’s additional torque and IP56 rating (dust and water resistance) make it more suitable for extreme conditions like construction sites or outdoor work.
How do the batteries compare between the Milwaukee 2967-20 and the Makita XWT08Z?
Both models use highly regarded battery systems, but they differ in platform:
- Milwaukee 2967-20 uses the M18 battery system, which is widely compatible with other Milwaukee tools. The M18 platform is known for its fast charging and long-lasting power, especially with the REDLITHIUM™ technology.
- Makita XWT08Z uses the 18V LXT lithium-ion battery system. While it may not charge as quickly as the M18 system, the LXT batteries offer great run-time and are also compatible with a large range of Makita tools.
Both systems are excellent, but if you already own tools from either brand, sticking with the same system might provide extra value due to compatibility.
Which impact wrench is lighter and easier to handle for long projects?
The Milwaukee 2967-20 is lighter and more compact, weighing about 7 pounds. This makes it easier to handle for extended periods without straining your wrist or hand. If you plan on using the wrench for long hours or in tight spaces, its lightweight design is a big advantage.
The Makita XWT08Z weighs a bit more, around 7.9 pounds, but it offers a well-balanced design, which can reduce fatigue, even with the added weight.
Does the Milwaukee 2967-20 have an LED light for working in low-light conditions?
Yes, the Milwaukee 2967-20 features an integrated LED light. This small but powerful light illuminates your work area, making it easier to work in dim environments such as dark garages or when performing roadside repairs at night. This feature is a great convenience for professionals and DIYers alike.
Is the Makita XWT08Z more durable than the Milwaukee 2967-20?
Yes, the Makita XWT08Z is generally more durable. With its IP56 rating, it offers superior protection against dust and water. This makes it more resilient for outdoor work or in environments with moisture, dust, or dirt. The Milwaukee 2967-20 has an IP54 rating, which is still excellent for most tasks, but it offers slightly less protection than the Makita.
If you expect to work in extreme conditions, the Makita XWT08Z is the better choice for durability.
What types of tasks can I use the Milwaukee 2967-20 and Makita XWT08Z for?
Both the Milwaukee 2967-20 and Makita XWT08Z are designed for heavy-duty tasks like:
- Automotive repairs: Removing lug nuts, engine parts, and suspension components.
- Construction: Fastening bolts in structural components or machinery.
- Home improvement: Installing large fixtures or deck building.
- Heavy machinery maintenance: Working on industrial equipment.
While both tools are versatile, the Makita XWT08Z is better suited for extreme tasks that require more power, while the Milwaukee 2967-20 is great for general heavy-duty use.
Does the Makita XWT08Z have a brushless motor?
Yes, the Makita XWT08Z features a brushless motor, which offers several benefits:
- More efficient power usage, leading to longer battery life.
- Less maintenance, as there are no brushes to wear out.
- Improved durability, as brushless motors generate less heat.
The Milwaukee 2967-20 also has a brushless motor (Powerstate technology), which provides similar benefits in terms of efficiency, longer tool life, and better performance.
Which impact wrench has the best value for money?
The Milwaukee 2967-20 offers great value for money because it provides solid performance at a lower price point, usually around $200 to $300. If you’re looking for a reliable and powerful tool without breaking the bank, the Milwaukee is a great choice.
On the other hand, the Makita XWT08Z, priced around $300 to $350, is more expensive but offers higher torque and better protection for extreme work conditions. If you need extra power and durability and can justify the price, the Makita XWT08Z could be a better investment.
Can I use these impact wrenches for small DIY projects?
Yes, both the Milwaukee 2967-20 and Makita XWT08Z can be used for DIY projects. While they are both designed for heavy-duty work, they are more than capable of handling home improvement projects, such as:
- Installing large screws and bolts
- Building furniture
- Tightening nuts for vehicle maintenance
- Minor repairs on machinery or home appliances
However, if your DIY projects are typically light-duty, you might find these models a bit overkill. If you only need occasional use for smaller tasks, a more compact and less expensive model might suffice.
How long do the batteries last on these impact wrenches?
Battery life can vary depending on the tasks you’re performing, but generally speaking:
- With the Milwaukee 2967-20, the M18 5.0Ah battery can last a good amount of time on most applications, providing extended run-time between charges. Milwaukee’s REDLITHIUM™ battery technology also ensures longer life and better performance than standard lithium-ion batteries.
- The Makita XWT08Z uses 18V LXT batteries, which also offer excellent run-time and quick charging capabilities. Depending on the battery capacity (like 5.0Ah), you can expect similar performance to the Milwaukee battery system.
Both tools offer long battery life, but if you’re working on larger projects, investing in a spare battery for continuous use is always a good idea.
Which brand is better, Milwaukee or Makita?
Both Milwaukee and Makita are top-tier brands in the power tools industry, and each has its own strengths:
- Milwaukee is known for its innovation, affordability, and wide range of compatible tools. The M18 battery system is incredibly popular among professionals.
- Makita is recognized for its durability, advanced motor technology (brushless motors), and rugged design. The LXT system is also highly regarded, particularly for outdoor and extreme-use conditions.
Ultimately, both brands offer exceptional tools, so your choice will depend on your specific needs, budget, and which system (M18 or LXT) you prefer.
Are the Milwaukee 2967-20 and Makita XWT08Z suitable for professional use?
Yes, both the Milwaukee 2967-20 and Makita XWT08Z are suitable for professional use. They are designed to handle demanding tasks in industries like automotive repair, construction, and maintenance. With their powerful motors, excellent torque, and durable build, either one would be a reliable tool for professionals.
